Bitter pill: Govt surrenders $200m industry to Australian control

Monday, December 8th 2003

• Tweet

By Sue Kedgley MP, Green Party Health Spokseperson.

The Health Minister has effectively given Australia control of New Zealand's $200 million dietary supplements industry, Green MP Sue Kedgley charged today.

"The Minister's unilateral decision to regulate the industry through an agency based in Australia, staffed primarily by Australians, governed by an Australian-dominated board and set up under Australian law, makes a travesty of New Zealand sovereignty," said Ms Kedgley, the Green Health spokesperson.

Ms Kedgley pointed out that the new agency would be an expanded version of an existing Australian agency. It will have far reaching powers, including the power of search and seizure, enforcement powers and the ability to make what are essentially policy decisions without recourse to the New Zealand parliament.

"The Australian-based Managing Director of the Agency will have extraordinary powers, including the authority to make delegated legislation in the form of Rules and Orders, which will have a direct effect in New Zealand but will not to be incorporated into domestic legislation.

"These unprecedented powers are not found anywhere in the New Zealand public service and are probably unconstitutional," said Ms Kedgley.

Just a fortnight ago another trans-Tasman regulator, the Food Regulation Ministerial Council, refused to release any of their papers under the Official Information Act, on the grounds that they were an international organisation. "We are witnessing a disturbing pattern of policy making and regulation being placed out of reach of New Zealand citizens," warned Ms Kedgley.

"This is a shocking decision and it's pathetic to see the Minister of Health flailing around trying to blame the select committee, and myself, for her outrageous decision to ignore our year-long inquiry and sign a treaty with Australia before the select committee has even reported back to Parliament."

Ms Kedgley predicted the move would contravene the government's own commitment to reducing the compliance costs of small business by significantly increasing costs across the industry and inevitably forcing many small dietary supplements businesses to the wall.

Footnote from Ideal Health

It is very disappointing that the Government chooses to ignore the Select committee processes and the submissions made by the health industry and the public of New Zealand.

If you want to be able to continue to purchase and choose the health supplements you want to take, you need to immediately get in touch with your local MP and tell them how concerned you are about the Harmonisation with Australia. We are VERY concerned and you should be too. If enough people complain, they may listen.

Related articles can be found here:

Complementary Health Response Disappoints Sue Kedgley

Govt Suffers Setback on Trans-Tasman Plans

NZ Health Trust Newsletter

Pharmac Warns Huge Fees Will Price Medicines Off the Shelf

Rules Body 'Will Limit New Drugs'

SPEECH - ALLISON ROE, JUNE 16TH 2006

Speech by Green Health spokesperson Sue Kedgley to the Natural Healthcare Policy Debate

When Is a Lie Not a Lie?

If you need help or advice, you are welcome to email our naturopathic team with your health question.

Disclaimer: The health information presented here has been written for the New Zealand health consumer. It is of a general nature and is only intended to provide a summary of the subjects covered. The information is not intended to be comprehensive or to provide medical advice to you. While all care has been taken to ensure the accuracy of the information, no responsibility or liability is accepted, and no person should act in reliance on any statement contained in the information provided. All health ailments should be treated by a qualified health professional.

ref:n169

• Tweet